diff --git a/Modules/Quest/QuestieQuest.lua b/Modules/Quest/QuestieQuest.lua
index d46cf27..a2be8ff 100644
--- a/Modules/Quest/QuestieQuest.lua
+++ b/Modules/Quest/QuestieQuest.lua
@@ -781,7 +781,13 @@ function QuestieQuest:GetAllQuestIds()
                 -- Only draw the source item objective when the quest is not yet complete.
                 -- If the quest is complete (complete == 1), the source item was consumed during
                 -- the quest (e.g. Cold Iron Key for quest 12843) and should not draw its drop NPC.
-                if complete ~= 1 then
+                if complete == 1 then
+                    -- Mark the quest object as complete so QuestieArrow collects finisher spawns
+                    -- instead of objective spawns. Without this, the arrow falls through to the
+                    -- objective collection path and picks up any stale fake item objectives.
+                    quest.isComplete = true
+                    quest.WasComplete = true
+                else
                     QuestieQuest:CheckQuestSourceItem(questId, true)
                 end
                 QuestieQuest:PopulateQuestLogInfo(quest)